Never thought I'd say this, but resigning Ike has got to be a priority this offseason. They probably need to go CB in round 1 or 2 as well.
I'd have to agree. B/T Ike and McFad, it's not even close. I really miss Deshea Townsend more and more this season.
However, is Ike that good or McFad that bad? No one throws Ike's direction because the other side of the field is so attractive. It's obvious that we're trying to hide him. Hell, when you have Ryan Clark matching up man on Boldin, you don't have a lot of confidence in your CB.
I think McFad is like a lot of our corners in recent years: Looks good as the nickel, but can't step up to be the man.