Ellie blows

[Preacherman0]

Peyton is clearly THE Manning in this league.

Ellie and the Dopey Moon Face stink, along with the Giants.  Yeah, he and Romo are MUCH better than Rofelingsbarger.

[P4P]

Now preacher.  WWJD?

[Merman1983]

Hate Peyton, still can't bring myself to hate Eli based his part in the 18-1*.

[LambertsFrontTeeth]

Ditto that. I hated him prior, but, I shed a tear of joy for the little guy when he caused that calamity.

He does suck, though.

[aj_law]

Yeah, he and Romo are MUCH better than Rofelingsbarger.

Dunno where you hear that kind of stuff, P.  I never hear Eli or Romo put into Ben's class.  At least, not by people that understand football.

If you're ranking based on a Tier System, guys like Eli and Romo would be Tier III, IMO.  Ben would be either bottom of Tier I or very top of Tier II.  Where he falls is pretty much predicated on how large you want to make each Tier.

Top 5, no question.

Oh, and it's Rapelsburger.  Get it right.

[Preacherman0]

Now preacher.  WWJD?

Matthew 16:23

[Preacherman0]

Dunno where you hear that kind of stuff, P.  I never hear Eli or Romo put into Ben's class.  At least, not by people that understand football.

Well now, that's the real trick, isn't it? 

Don't hear it nearly as much since Ben racked up XLIII, but there are still some pundits, radio guys, etc. who don't give Ben the credit that he deserves, and offer way too much credit to Ellie and Romo.  Keep hearing how Romo is so "talented," but what he done?

<<YU STOOPIT SHIPDIT...YOO CANT EFEN SPIL ROFLINGSBARGETT>>>

[jonzr]

That's the perception of the perception that I have.  Not so much for Ellie but for sure with Romo, for whatever reason.  Ben is still viewed as a caretaker and the beneficiary of a great defense.  Romo is the jedi who racks up pretty stats and it's just a matter of time for guys like him and Phirrip Livers *quote fingers*

[P4P]

Now preacher.  WWJD?

Matthew 16:23

That he would, Preach.  That he would.